Red Dye No. 3 is BANNED! 🚨 How Dog Treat Bakers Can Adapt

February 25, 2025 Pawsitive Profit

Amazon Affiliate Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting my work!

Red Dye No. 3 is BANNED! Now What?

Imagine spending hours perfecting your best-selling, brightly colored dog treats... only to find out that one of your go-to ingredients is now banned by the FDA. Yep, we’re talking about Red Dye No. 3—the same dye that’s been making treats look vibrant is now officially off the menu!

But before you panic, let’s break down what this means for your dog treat business—and how you can turn this into an opportunity instead of a headache.

Let’s be real—most of us didn’t start our businesses thinking, “Hmm, I bet one day I’ll have to deal with ingredient bans.” But here we are! And trust me, this isn’t the first or last time something like this will happen. The key is knowing how to pivot like a pro.

So, grab your coffee (or your pup’s favorite snack), and let’s dive in!

Elegant and paw-sitively delightful! These pink macaron-inspired dog treats bring a gourmet touch to your pup’s snack time

Why This Ban Matters to You

The FDA has officially banned Red Dye No. 3 in food and treats, including those for dogs.

Why? Because studies have linked it to potential health risks, and regulators finally decided it’s time to phase it out.

If you’re thinking, “Wait, but I’ve been eating and selling treats with this dye for years!”—you’re not alone. This dye has been around since the 1900s and was even banned in cosmetics decades ago. But now that it’s officially out of food, we’ve got to adapt.

Imagine this scenario: You own a thriving dog treat business, and one of your best-sellers is a bright red strawberry biscuit. You’ve built your brand around fun, colorful treats that stand out in the market. Suddenly, this ban drops, and you’re wondering…

Is my business doomed?!

🚨 Short answer? No.
🚀 Long answer? Only if you ignore this change instead of rolling with it.

Let’s talk about what this actually means for your dog treat bakery.

Banned ingredients = recipe adjustments! Dog treat bakers must now find safe, natural replacements for Red Dye No. 3 to keep their treats both colorful and compliant.

How the Ban Affects Dog Treat Bakers

Here’s how this change might impact your business:

✅ If you use commercial food coloring, you’ll need to check your ingredients and find alternatives.
✅ If your branding is heavily tied to brightly colored treats, you may need to rethink your product aesthetics.
✅ If you buy pre-made mixes, some of your suppliers might need to adjust their formulas—and that could mean recipe tweaks on your end.
✅ If you sell in stores or online, customers might start asking about natural alternatives, so it’s time to get ahead of the trend.

Let’s break it down even further. Suppose you’re at a farmers’ market selling your adorable, vibrant treats. A customer picks up a red one and says, “Oh wow, what gives it this color?” And you realize... uh-oh, you haven’t switched yet. You don’t want to be caught off guard, right?

And let’s not forget about wholesalers and pet stores. If you supply to them, they will expect you to update your ingredient lists. The last thing you want is to get pulled from shelves over this.

So let’s get ahead of it!

What’s in your frosting? Many bright red icings contain Red Dye No. 3, a chemical now banned in California. It’s time to switch to safer options for dog treats!

What to Do Next: Your Game Plan

Step 1: Audit Your Ingredients

🔎 Check your current recipes and product labels. If you’re using anything with Red Dye No. 3, start sourcing a replacement now. If you’re unsure, check with your suppliers—better safe than scrambling at the last minute!

Step 2: Switch to Natural Alternatives

Ditch artificial dyes! Natural alternatives like beetroot powder and freeze-dried strawberries can give your dog treats a vibrant red hue—without the risks of Red Dye No. 3.

Now, I know what you’re thinking—"Natural colors won’t be as vibrant!" And you’re kinda right… but also kinda wrong.

There are amazing alternatives that can give you that eye-catching look without the artificial stuff:

👉 Beet powder for a deep red
👉 Freeze-dried strawberry powder for a soft pink
👉 Turmeric powder for a golden hue

💡 Pro Tip: Experiment with these natural ingredients and test different quantities to find the perfect shade and intensity for your treats!

Dog treat bakers, check your labels! Red Dye No. 3 is still found in many food products—make sure your treats are free of harmful artificial colors

Final Thoughts & Next Steps

🚨 The Red Dye No. 3 ban is NOT the end of your business. It’s a chance to get creative, stand out, and even promote your treats as a healthier, all-natural option!

✅ Audit your ingredients NOW so you’re not caught off guard.
✅ Start testing natural alternatives to keep your treats looking amazing.
✅ Be transparent with customers and let them know you’re adapting to the new regulations.

🐾 Want more business tips? Join our free Dog Treat Business Facebook Community for expert advice, live Q&As, and support from fellow treat bakers!

Warmest woofs,

Kara 🧡